Search This Blog

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Property in Mumbai - the biggest metropolis of India

It is but natural that people flock to cities – a city life, however miserable could be is the dream choice as millions of village youths [both men and women] chase their pipedream – once it was believed that at least 50 girls land up at Egmore Railway station  from small villages down south, aspiring to get a role in the silver screen, thinking it to be the gateway to prosperity. 

Amongst the 4 metropolis, to most Mumbai represents the most posh, cosmopolitan, wealthy, progressive,  city of opportunities.  We tend to think that in Mumbai people live in plush flats chasing wealth…… here is an article read in ‘The Economist’ –  which gives a newer perspective to Mumbai life. 

Property in Mumbai  :  The minimum city
Is the world’s weirdest property market strangling the city that hosts it?   Jun 9th 2012 | MUMBAI | from the ‘’

IN THE minds of Mumbai residents, whether they sleep on streets or silk sheets, property developers loom large. In films and novels, skyscraper-erecting baddies bring wealth and renewal—and often misery and violence. Yet in reality, buildings do not loom as large as you might think in Mumbai.

Take the view from one of the towers clustered in midtown, owned by Abhisheck Lodha, a razor-sharp American-educated tycoon making billion-dollar bets on transforming the city. The odd skyscraper erupts out of low-rise clutter. There are pockets of tall buildings on old mill land and along the city’s west coast. But much of Mumbai—supposedly a rival to Hong Kong, London and New York—looks flat and knackered. To the east the vista is of derelict factories, rotting low-rise rent-controlled buildings and the odd slum. To the south lies the ossifying old city centre, with its ageing port, colonial showpieces and Soviet-style offices and bureaucrats’ flats. The nearest green spaces are a racecourse and a club on whose ample lawn members feed stray dogs buttered toast.

Mumbai has perhaps the most extreme statistics of any metropolis. Its land mass is small, stuck like a crooked blade into the Arabian Sea. It has poor transport links, so people who work in the city live near it. That in turn means it has the highest population density of any big city. But it is also low-rise. Panama City has a taller skyline.

The result is tiny living spaces of 4.5 square metres (48 square feet) per person, compared with 34 square metres in Shanghai. And prices are high. Mid-town flats cost $1m-3m. The average price of a 1,000-square-foot pad in the city is perhaps $250,000, or 90 times GDP per head. With flats out of reach, the share of people in slums has risen to perhaps 60%, compared with 20% in Rio de Janeiro and Delhi. Of the rest, about half live in rent-controlled digs, sometimes propped up by wooden staves, or flats for public-sector employees.

Other cities confined by the sea, from New York to Hong Kong, have soared upwards. Many think Mumbai has had an epic building boom. There has been dense activity on old mill land and in some suburbs where rules are laxer. But the city has 31 buildings over 100 metres high, versus more than 200 in Shanghai and more than 500 in Hong Kong and New York. Perhaps $10 billion-20 billion has been spent on land and building in the past decade, not much given that the population has risen to 12m. At the current rate it will take over six decades to build everyone a home.

Much of the building has targeted the well-off with often magnificent complexes. But are there enough wealthy people? “It’s hard to find homeless millionaires,” says a developer. At the current pace of sales it would take three years to clear the stock of 28,000-odd unsold flats in the city which are complete or being built, according to Ashutosh Limaye, of Jones Lang LaSalle, a property-services firm. Pankaj Kapoor, of Liases Foras, a research firm, puts the figures at 38,000 and four years.

So inefficient and cartelised is the market that prices are still rising, despite the overhang, a weak economy and the debt troubles of some builders. (Listed Indian firms which make public their accounts, and are about a fifth of the industry, are often in poor shape.) One builder, from his private drinking den in the city’s north, is full of foreboding about his trade. “All the bad karma is coming back. All the Porsches and Lamborghinis, all the bodyguards and security details; it’s all coming back.”

Flat-packing humans
Three things explain Mumbai’s predicament: regulations, financing and graft. The city, reckons Edward Glaeser of Harvard University, has “some of the most extreme land-use restrictions in the developing world”, designed to deter new migrants but which have backfired. In much of the city the ratio of a new building’s floor space to the plot it is built on is capped at 1.3 times (compared with over five times in New York and Hong Kong). Rules inhibit new construction near the coast. Because of the thicket of red tape and litigation, only 3% of 15,000 rent-controlled buildings have been redeveloped, says Subodh Kumar, who retired as Mumbai’s top official in April. Bits of idle land, including the old port, lie stranded because of vested interests. Rare free plots can command staggering prices.

Finance also plays a role. Mortgages are common but banks cannot fund land purchases. Developers finance construction by forcing customers to pay upfront, often without redress if the project stalls. The industry says it has cleaned up its act and attracted institutional investors. Still, it is not unusual to make an under-the-table cash payment of at least 20% in addition to the stated price. The limited role of banks protects financial stability, but has other costs. If builders are nervous about demand or short of cash, they can halt construction, having already got customers’ cash. And non-bank finance is not always kosher. One fraud expert reckons 80% of money-laundering in India uses property.

In Navi (or “New”) Mumbai, across the bay from the city, lots of newish flats have empty balconies and no air-conditioning units—clues they are vacant. Local agents say they are held as investments. Without banks breathing down their necks, developers and owners sit on empty flats, rather than cut prices; this is a housing market where more borrowing might be helpful. And if illicit money is involved, there is little impulse to sell since the only thing it can easily be recycled into is more real estate.

Corruption adds a final twist. Many firms say times have changed and things are above board. But it is clear that some builders still bribe officials and politicians. The prizes range from being allowed bigger balconies to the support of politicians with “vote banks” in slums being redeveloped. Mr Kumar tried to clean things up after finding that “builders and architects worked the system”. Another official says, “politicians and all kinds of manipulators are made sleeping partners” in projects. One boss says the height rules are “the biggest mafia scam in India” and are a vital source of funding for political parties.

The only way is up
The textbook solution for Mumbai is better transport and many more high-rises, to increase the supply of flats and lower prices. It might help if the city had more political autonomy, as Delhi does. (At the moment Mumbai is part of Maharashtra, a giant, partly rural state.) That is some way off. Still, there are rays of hope. The first overhead metro line, in the north of the city, and a short stretch of monorail running north-to-south, should open in a couple of years. Ajay Piramal, who began the redevelopment of mill land two decades ago and who is re-entering the industry, says graft has fallen since Mr Kumar’s crackdown. Officials say they are trying to spur pockets of redevelopment. And a new national property regulator is in the works.

Yet, says P.K. Das, an urban planner, the system is just too rotten to allow a Hong Kong-style building frenzy. The industry is “feudal”, has “subverted” the law and may need to be nationalised. While the city needs more skyscrapers, an unregulated building spree would be counterproductive unless the state gets cleaner, and better at planning and providing infrastructure such as roads, sewage and water. Already many feel the city is falling behind Delhi and Bangalore.

Great cities are not built by prudes—New York had its share of crooks and fat cats once. But Mumbai is already four times more populous than New York in 1900, and is in a hurry. The conspiracy theory, held by the man on the street and captains of industry, is that transport projects are delayed and arcane rules survive because a small elite finds the status quo lucrative, even while the city’s development is strangled. If Mumbai is to become a global hub and offer more people a decent life, its politicians, officials and builders must prove the conspiracy theory wrong.

Reproduced in its entirety – as found interesting read :


  1. Now, its very easy to get your dream Home and get best deals on it.

  2. hi nice post thanks for posting . it is great post

    property in Mumbai

  3. The real estate market in Mumbai has increased tremendously compared to the first quarter of this year!

  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

  5. Thank you for sharing the valuable information about Property in Ghazizbad in this blog.

  6. I was finding this kind of Residential spaces of 4.5 square metres (48 square feet) per person, compared with 34 square metres in Shanghai. Here i gather this information thanks ................!!!!!!!!!!!
    Gurgaon Properties

  7. This comment has been removed by the author.

  8. I always imagine living in Mumbai. Now I am working in Software Company in Pune. Pune is an India’s Premiere IT Hub. This is the main reason I am looking for Apartments in Pune. The apartment must be fully furnished, Must contains a swimming pool, Party Lawn, Basket Ball Court and Children Play Area.

  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

  10. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  11. Kalpataru Aura

    Kalpataru Group launched new residential project KALPATARU AURA at Ghatkopar West in Mumbai. Kalpataru Aura offers 2 and 2.5 bedroom apartments with modern Features.

  12. I agree with you that Mumbai has perhaps the most extreme statistics of any metropolis. Its land mass is small, stuck liking a crooked blade into the Arabian Sea. It has poor transport links, so people who work in the city live near it. That in turn means it has the highest population density of any big city. It is also true that finding Residential Property In Mumbai is also very difficult.

  13. The real estate market in Pune has improved enormously compared to the first quarter of this year! Yes true..

    Real Estate in Pune

  14. Thank you for sharing the valuable information about Property in Mumbai in this blog.

    Pune Real Estate

  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

  16. This comment has been removed by the author.

  17. Someone said truth about real estate Mumbai which is the real estate market in Mumbai has enlarged extremely equated to the first quarter of this year!

    Properties For sale in Pune

  18. This is really a nice blog. I follow your blog since long time. I like the way you write and share latest information on real estate market. Thanks for sharing grateful information on Pune real estate.

    Properties For sale in Pune

  19. Mumbai is one the economical place, as there the only bollywood industry. if looking to invest in Lease of commercial space in Delhi

  20. Many firms say times have changed and things are above board. But it is clear that some builders still bribe officials and politicians. This is the main problem with India.

    Buy Property in Delhi

  21. Lease Of Commercial Space in Delhi guarantees a variety of possibilities that are as opposed to any other places in the country. If Searching for new Commercial Property in Delhi Ncr or planning to transfer your business, places such as Delhi Central, India are value considering.

  22. Kalpataru Aura Mumbai Property

    Kalpataru Group launched new residential project KALPATARU AURA at Ghatkopar West in Mumbai. Kalpataru Aura offers 2 and 2.5 bedroom apartments with modern Features.

  23. I must thank уou for the effoгts you've put in penning this blog. I really hope to see the same high-grade blog posts from you in the future as well.

    Residential Property For Sale in Pune

  24. Property in Mumbai is growing faster than other cities of India, most of the customers are coming across it and showing their interests in it.

    Property at pune

  25. Hi there, just wanted to tell you, I liked this post.
    It was funny. Keep on posting!

    Feel free to visit my site selling my house home fast

  26. Attractive section of content. I just stumbled upon your
    site and in accession capital to assert that I get actually
    enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I will be
    subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently fast.

    Feel free to visit my website; Houston SEO

  27. Hi there everyone, it's my first visit at this website, and piece of
    writing is genuinely fruitful in support of me, keep up posting these posts.

    My webpage: Seo Company Services;,

  28. Most likely not, but does it help to keep your iPhone from getting damaged through typical wear and tear?
    Galaxy II how to unlock iphone 4s offers microSD slot so that you have
    over nuts-and-bolts! From what we how to unlock iphone 4s understand, you'll
    be able to recommend this app, you will love Bejeweled 2.
    4 million customers, lost 515, 000 contract customers in the US.

    Here is my web-site - iPhone 4 unlock ()

  29. Now, though, is the German agency Sixt, which has been shut out of quill coupons financial markets because of the trend, he said.

    My blog post - quill promo code ()

  30. I have been surfing online greater than 3 hours
    lately, but I never discovered any fascinating article like yours.
    It's beautiful worth sufficient for me. In my view, if all site owners and bloggers made good content material as you did,
    the internet will likely be much more helpful than ever before.

    my weblog: Daily Eye Restoration Review

  31. This article presents clear idea for the new visitors of
    blogging, that actually how to do blogging.

    my webpage Seo Company

  32. Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as I provide credit and sources back to your webpage?

    My blog is in the very same area of interest as yours and my users would truly benefit from a lot of the information you
    present here. Please let me know if this alright
    with you. Cheers!

    my webpage - Pure Garcinias

  33. I think this is one of the most significant information for me.
    And i'm glad reading your article. But should
    remark on few general things, The website style is wonderful, the
    articles is really great : D. Good job, cheers

    my page; calories burned calculator

  34. I was recommended this website by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is
    written by him as nobody else know such detailed about
    my problem. You're incredible! Thanks!

    Check out my page: Webcam roulette

  35. Deep emotion must be present; otherwise, you cannot
    transmit something you do not wear, you are bound
    psychic readings by phone to be correct. Find a real online psychic today and learn
    what you need to know their loved ones are doing fine in the
    spirit world. More times than not breaking off
    a relationship can be an unnecessarily prolonged and painful
    process. Unfortunately, will no growth in Europe or Japan and tepid job as well as GDP growth domestically; organically increasing sales and earnings will be
    a beautiful and aesthetically appealing piece of hardware.

    Here is my blog post: psychic reviews - ,

  36. They are intended to provide a relative guide as to the diatomaceous earth benefits actual size these creatures will be when you encounter
    them. And what we're doing diatomaceous earth benefits this year and
    that was our purchase in fourth quarter last year. Now foreign currency translation, based upon current exchange rates,
    we now have become the guinea pigs.

  37. When someone writes an paragraph he/she retains the idea of a user in his/her mind that how a user can know it.
    So that's why this post is great. Thanks!

    Look at my page ... Muscle Rev X Review (Http://

  38. You can definitely see your skills within the article you write.
    The sector hopes for more passionate writers such as you who
    are not afraid to mention how they believe. Always go after your heart.

    my webpage - Top 10 Extreme Weight Loss Diets ()

  39. Generally, these types of applications function by using an authenticated username and password.
    ll need will be the best hardware and the best software. This
    company relies upon the fact that most people are computer illiterate and will
    likely leave it in place and purchase it, so this company in a sense has cornered the market and
    does very little research and development to the latest viruses that might peek their
    head into your system.

    My blog post: what does dsl mean

  40. Highly descriptive post, I liked that bit. Will there be a part 2?

    my webpage :: quill Promo Code (

  41. I have read so many posts concerning the blogger lovers except this article is genuinely a
    nice post, keep it up.

    Feel free to surf to my blog post; natural Garcinia Cambogia Supplement (

  42. Hi there, just became aware of your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative.
    I'm gonna watch out for brussels. I will appreciate if you continue this in
    future. Numerous people will be benefited from your writing.

    Here is my web-site: Cenaless Dieting

  43. Parents must teach their kids especially very young ones
    about the dangers lurking on the internet.

    When you spend more on the case you get more features, better quality and better cooling.
    The original Game Boy was packaged with Tetris (and Tetris' immense popularity
    helped drive the handheld's sales), so there's certainly
    nothing wrong with puzzle games fueling the initial interest in a system.

    my weblog ... Skidrow games

  44. These deposits can raise the size of a golf ball by keeping up a crystalline formation.
    Vitamin A is an essential ingredient for healthy kidneys.
    When the uric acid levels are increase in the blood
    it promotes the kidney stones formation.

    Have a look at my web page - Clair's hair treatment

  45. For this reason things can get easily complicated if it is not dealt with proper
    care and attention. There are numerous options as far as bankruptcy lawyer Miami is concerned.
    The california bankruptcy lawyers or virtually any lawyer for instance
    could be there to work with you so as to.

    My page ... Mississauga lawyers

  46. Mumbai-the city of dreams,and the city which never sleeps,Thanks for the blog on property,it is very informative ,for investment in real estate South Mumbai now affordable only by big guns in the market.With increase in dollar rate,many NRI's are investing in real estate in Mumbai

  47. This comment has been removed by the author.

  48. If you want to buy a commercial/residential property in gurgaon.Please call us on +91-9650019588 for immediate booking with best discount.

  49. Good article. I agree with the author. As I am living in Mumbai I know all the major places. The properties rates in Mumbai are greater than that of other cities properties.

    2 BHK Flats in Khopoli

  50. Yes. Mumbai is biggest metropolis of India. Real estate market of both residential and commercial property always high. India's number 1 city.

    industrial land in ambernath

  51. Your post is really providing good information.. I liked it and enjoyed reading it. Keep sharing such important posts

    Hyderabad Properites

  52. This comment has been removed by the author.

  53. This comment has been removed by the author.

  54. The Real estate industry is considered a growth engine of the economy. It is one of the fastest growing sectors of the Indian economy and plays a vital role in overall growth and development.
    Properties in Mumbai.

  55. Worth reading post thanks for sharing such informative post about the real estate of Mumbai.

    Mumbai Realty

  56. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.